Pootleflump wrote:...
I also don't think it's any of our business to speculate as to why people have dropped off the site or come back again.
I completely disagree, Pootle.
Of course do we have a right to know what's happening.
After all, he stressed the time of so many people. He was setting himself above others by taking over the conversations at the forum and the chat, presenting himself as an "expert", creating rules (tournament), answering arrogantly to votes at the forum, calling for articles for his "zine", opening a new tab (blog) on the website, becoming a moderator with special rights.
These are PROMISES, right? It means implicitly that he promises to fulfill the self-imposed commitments towards the others, in exchange for a prominent "social position" and special rights (e.g. as a moderator).
He makes people to invest hours and days to write intelligent zine articles, months to participate and stay with a tournament. He asks people to invest some of their lifetime for him and his projects.
And then he disappears just like this? That's not normal and we have the right to know what's going on.
Of course, he could suffer a stroke, or die, or get catched and jailed in, etc. Then I would say: aahw.. poor boy, or RIP, or whatever is appropriate..
But still: why does nobody know what happened. I hear that he had meticulously hidden his identity. Why is that? What has he to hide? To become a moderator on playdip, isn't one asked for his RL identity, phone number and other contact data and/or references?
Then another point of my contemplations: When somebody gets so much active, has many projects, deals with people and organizes them, he needs a lot of time for that, right? He would spend a good part of the day doing this. So, normally that would not get unnoticed by persons in his environment. They would ask: what are you doing, and he would show them what he does and tell them about Playdiplomacy, the zine, the tournament. NORMALLY. And if then something happens like a stroke or so, they would be able to send a short notice to the community, in whatever form that be, to say that the patient would not return.
EXCEPT.. if he has done all this in complete isolation, in a closed little room, a mansard, a remote Norwegian hut.. (*imaginating all these settings*). Bref, except if he was a VERY LONELY person.
Any other proposals that could explain it?
I am still in a very beginning phase of my trial to understand the psychology behind such behaviour. I need more signs and observations, and I might have some more questions shortly.
What I can say already is, that when somebody comes and swings himself up WITHIN A SHORT TIME, in a community like e.g. Playdiplomacy, then caution is advisable, and measures should be taken like RL identity check, references, contact possibilities outside of the online channels of that community.
Regards.. Jack