Mafia CLXII: Planeswalker Mafia, Town Win

[kimpossible]

@sjg: I think it get you; you have a solid reason to SR Chuck. You don't have the solidity to SR AKFD because he could have been stumbling over his words.

Would you agree it bears further examination though? His wording doesn't give me reason to townclear and potentially raises my suspicion, even if it isn't damning.

PPE: Yeah, I can go along with UDC.

[Blackswimmer]

Also, heads up Sjg I don't think you've entered your vote into the tabulator yet.

[kimpossible]

Also, heads up Sjg I don't think you've entered your vote into the tabulator yet.

You beat me to it.

[Dwiltse1114]

It certainly never crossed my mind to propose a creature reveal. Anyone else think of that?

I would be ok if everyone reveals weather or not they have creatures but leave out the power/toughness of those creatures...

Then again at the same time this allows scum to target those without creatures and could possibly eliminate multiple players tonight depending on how many loyalty points everyone has...

[kimpossible]

It certainly never crossed my mind to propose a creature reveal. Anyone else think of that?

I would be ok if everyone reveals weather or not they have creatures but leave out the power/toughness of those creatures...

Then again at the same time this allows scum to target those without creatures and could possibly eliminate multiple players tonight depending on how many loyalty points everyone has...

If sjg is correct it's a moot point for N1, which also actually makes sense from a game balance perspective. If all town-controlled creatures must be summoned first, scum get one night with better odds of getting a kill through.

[Blackswimmer]

It certainly never crossed my mind to propose a creature reveal. Anyone else think of that?

I would be ok if everyone reveals weather or not they have creatures but leave out the power/toughness of those creatures...

Then again at the same time this allows scum to target those without creatures and could possibly eliminate multiple players tonight depending on how many loyalty points everyone has...

Dwilt, are you up to date on everything that's happened? If so, do you agree with Sjg's theory?

[Dwiltse1114]

It certainly never crossed my mind to propose a creature reveal. Anyone else think of that?

I would be ok if everyone reveals weather or not they have creatures but leave out the power/toughness of those creatures...

Then again at the same time this allows scum to target those without creatures and could possibly eliminate multiple players tonight depending on how many loyalty points everyone has...

Dwilt, are you up to date on everything that's happened? If so, do you agree with Sjg's theory?

Im going to have to go back and reread udcs actual post when I get home later and get on my computer to confirm weather or not a I agree with that portion however based on information and general responses from

Blackswimmer
Sjg
Kim
(Obviously myself)

I feel like this is a solid core town circle that im comfortable with keeping from my Poe minus a scum slip or later game lylo situations

[Dwiltse1114]

Once I get home and on my computer ill get a vote up from what im reading it seems like a scum slip happened from udc but like I said ill check later

[GeneralHankerchief]

Does Playdip have early hammers/maj?

(i.e. if someone reaches a majority - not just a plurality - of votes partway through the day, does the dayphase immediately end with that person dying?)

[sjg11]

@sjg: I think it get you; you have a solid reason to SR Chuck. You don't have the solidity to SR AKFD because he could have been stumbling over his words.

Would you agree it bears further examination though? His wording doesn't give me reason to townclear and potentially raises my suspicion, even if it isn't damning.

PPE: Yeah, I can go along with UDC.

Broadly. Plus AK has shown uncertainty about whether we have Creatures or not. I saw none of that from Chuck with his plan.

If we get Chuck then sure it's at least a reasonable basis for poking AK.